However much South Dakota and the 8th Circuit Court of appeals apparently think so.
http://feministing.com/archives/009480.htmlOk, so I am all for informing someone of the actual risks of medical procedures. You know, actual medical risks of a procedure, like the potential for infection or nerve or muscle damage. But South Dakota's Informed Consent law is just fucking ridiculous. First off it mandates that doctors have to inform the patient that she's pregnant with a human being.
WTF?
In the words of the women at Feministe, "Because I was under the illusion I'd give birth to a dolphin."
Seriously, is there any adult, female human being who is competent to consent to medical treatment who doesn't know that when they're pregnant they are GOING TO HAVE A HUMAN BABY?!?!?!? ZOMG!!!!!
Granted the legal infantilization of and moron-ification of women has a long and lasting precedent, this does not make it ok. There's a lot of shit that has long and lasting precedent that isn't ok by our standards today, like slavery, child marriage and kidnapping your bride as an acceptable engagement tactic.
I cannot even believe the fucking gall of the people who drafted this law. "Aw, we don't think you pretty little gals really understand that when you get pregnant you could have a BABY! Not a puppy or a kitten, but an honest to gosh human BABY, so you really need to think about that, little missy. We know you'll make the 'right' choice."
This is insulting beyond all belief.
I also find "waiting periods" to be insulting. What they are in reality is nothing more than an added obstacle for women who have to travel great distances to get to a clinic that will perform abortions. No woman I have ever met has been all blase about abortion. It is a serious decision that no woman takes lightly. Honestly, for all that I KNEW without a shadow of a doubt that I didn't want a baby ever, when Ogre and I had a pregnancy scare, I thought the fuck out of my decision to potentially abort what turned out to be a practical joke by my hateful uterus.
And parental notification laws are just... Look, if she felt she could TELL her parents, she would have without YOU mandating it by law. All those laws do is get scared freaked out teenaged girls beat up by abusive fuckhead parents they couldn't talk to in the first place, OR it gets them kicked out of the house and onto the streets OR it gets them forced into carrying to term. If they're lucky they'll be allowed to adopt the baby out,* if their parents are anything like a lot of asshole parents in religiously oppressive shithole towns, they'll be forced to keep the child as "God's punishment for their sin" or because "You're not giving away my grandchild!" or whatever... Best case scenario is the girl winds up being mentally punished and tortured for her mistake for the rest of her fucking life by the people who are supposed to love and protect her.
It reminds me of one of my favorite Pro-choice bumperstickers: "If you can't trust me with a choice, how can you trust me with a child?"
And the whole "You may become suicidal after your abortion" thing is just... Here, go read this website:
http://www.imnotsorry.net/whythis.htm And if you want to see how the anti-choicers really think, or at least some of them, check out this website of stories from women's clinic workers about performing abortions on some of these "Right To Life" activists because their abortion was the only moral abortion:
http://mypage.direct.ca/w/writer/anti-tales.html*If the baby is white. I'm looking for the article written by a girl who was head of her Right to Life organization in high school, and her senior year got pregnant. When she called one of the "Choose Life" pro-adoption organizations she'd spent her teen years championing, and told them she was pregnant with an interracial child, they told her they couldn't help her.